Does running as an independent help in Nebraska?
Once, at the top of the ticket, for one candidate. Down the ballot, the numbers can't find it.
The last post argued that backing an independent for the Senate cost Nebraska the turnout boost that a Democratic nominee brought almost everywhere else this year. The obvious answer to that is: maybe, but an independent can win votes a Democrat can't. That's a fair point, and it can be tested. Nebraska has run party-backed candidates under both labels for several cycles now, at the top of the ticket, in the Legislature and on the statewide boards.
The short version: it worked once, in a big way, for Dan Osborn in 2024. By 2026 there was little left of it. And down the ballot, where the party has been recruiting nonpartisans to run in red districts, the data can't find any edge at all.
Osborn in 2024
2024 is the cleanest comparison Nebraska will ever get. Two Senate seats were on the same ballot, both against Republican incumbents. Osborn ran as an independent against Deb Fischer, and Preston Love Jr. ran as the Democrat against Pete Ricketts.
Measured against Harris on those same ballots, Osborn ran about 14 points ahead of the top of the ticket and Love ran about 4 points behind it. That's a gap of 18.5 points between two candidates on the same ballots, and Osborn ran ahead of Love in 91 of Nebraska's 93 counties.
Some of that is just what Senate candidates do. Across the 30 Senate races in 2024 with both a Democrat and a Republican on the ballot, the typical Democrat ran about three points ahead of Harris. Osborn ran about 11 points beyond that. For scale, Angus King in Maine ran about 13 and a half points ahead of Harris, while Bernie Sanders in Vermont ran even with her.
So something real happened in 2024. But the label and the candidate came as a package, and there was only one Osborn. There's no way to tell from these numbers how much was "independent" and how much was Osborn.
Osborn in 2026
This year Osborn ran again as an independent, now with the Democratic Party's backing, and the comparison is the governor's race. Osborn ran about two points ahead of Lynne Walz. Across 22 other states with both a Senate and a governor's race, the Senate candidate typically ran about a point behind the governor, which leaves Osborn roughly three points better than usual.
The two years use different yardsticks, Harris in 2024 and the governor's race in 2026, but the drop is hard to miss. Whatever the independent label was worth at the top of the ticket, by 2026 most of it was gone.
In the Legislature
The Legislature is where the party has leaned hardest on the idea. In red districts it has backed candidates who aren't registered Democrats, on the theory that they can reach voters a Democrat can't.
I looked at 46 contested Legislature races in 2022, 2024 and 2026 with a candidate on the party's side, 9 of whom weren't registered Democrats. For each one I measured how far the candidate ran ahead of or behind the top of the ticket in the same precincts. Then I compared candidates in districts that lean the same way, with incumbency and the year held fixed.
The candidates who weren't registered Democrats ran about half a point behind registered Democrats in similar districts. That's well within the noise. The plausible range runs from about five points worse to about three points better. Adding each side's spending, counting unclear registrations differently, or dropping races the party's allies didn't spend on doesn't change the picture. None of the versions finds a clear edge.
Why it looks like it works
There's a reason the idea feels true. In red districts, every candidate on the party's side runs ahead of the top of the ticket in Legislature races, and it doesn't matter what they're registered as. For every ten points redder a district is, the party's candidate runs about three points further ahead of the ticket.
That isn't the candidates. The same pattern shows up inside single races, precinct by precinct, with the candidates fixed, and it runs the same way in 42 of 45 races. It also doesn't show up in partisan races on the same ballots: in this year's races for attorney general, secretary of state, treasurer and U.S. House, it was essentially zero.
The likely explanation is that the Legislature's ballot is already nonpartisan. A Republican voter in a red district who would never vote for a "D" doesn't see a "D" on the Legislature line either. A nonpartisan ballot already gives every candidate that boost, so the independent label has nothing left to add.
On the state boards
The Board of Regents and the State Board of Education are also elected on a nonpartisan ballot, so they make a second test. The numbers are small, just 12 races and 4 candidates on the party's side who weren't registered Democrats. On average those 4 ran about one point ahead of the top of the ticket, and the registered Democrats ran about six points ahead. With district lean held fixed, not being a registered Democrat was worth about two and a half points less. That's too few races to be sure, but it points the same way as the Legislature.
What this does and doesn't show
This can't settle every question. Who runs as what isn't random. The party tends to back a nonpartisan where it thinks a Democrat can't win, and the nonpartisans who run are often people with a local name. So the comparison is between candidates in districts that lean the same way, not the same candidate running under two labels. With only 9 non-Democrats in the Legislature and 4 on the boards, a small edge could hide inside the noise.
The numbers can't rule out an edge of up to about three points. But nothing in them shows one, and the case for running independents down the ballot rests on a boost these numbers can't find. On a ballot without party labels, the boost belongs to the ballot. And as the last post showed, the cost of not running Democrats shows up in who turns out.
2026 figures are election-week unofficial counts. 2024 Senate and presidential results by state are from the MIT Election Data and Science Lab; Nebraska's precinct results are from the Secretary of State. Margins are two-party. Registration is from Nebraska's voter file, and in 2026 the party side is the candidate listed on the party's own candidate page. Spending is from Nebraska Accountability and Disclosure Commission filings.
First published on That's Not How This Works. Subscribe there to get each post by email.