Why Nebraska's Democratic base stayed home
Democratic turnout rose almost everywhere in 2026. It rose most where there was a Democrat running for the Senate.
The last post made the case that Nebraska didn’t miss the wave so much as miss its own voters. The Democratic vote in Omaha and Lincoln fell further than it did in the four Trump states where Democrats won or led. That leaves the obvious question: why here and not there?
How to measure it
The cleanest way to compare states is to look at how well each state’s Democratic counties held on to their voters from one election to the next. For every state, take the counties Harris carried in 2024 and count how many ballots they cast in 2026 for every 100 they cast for president in 2024. Do the same for the rest of the state. The difference between the two is the gap. When the gap is positive, the Democratic counties held their vote better than everyone else.
In Kansas and Iowa this year, the gap was about six points. In Texas it was five. In Mississippi it was thirteen. In Nebraska it was one.
Nebraska used to do this too
It’s tempting to say Omaha just doesn’t vote in midterms. The numbers don’t back that up. In 2018, which was also a good year for Democrats, Nebraska’s Democratic counties outperformed the rest of the state by four and a half points, right in line with Kansas and Iowa. The gap shrank everywhere in 2022, Nebraska included. In 2026 everyone else’s came back and Nebraska’s didn’t.
So whatever held Nebraska’s base down is about 2026 specifically.
What it wasn’t
It wasn’t a counting problem. These are the state’s final unofficial totals.
It wasn’t that 2024 was an unusually big year in Omaha, either. Omaha’s electoral vote has drawn both presidential campaigns, and the theory is that it pulls in voters who then skip midterms. Nebraska’s Democratic counties did grow their presidential electorate by about 14% between 2016 and 2024. But Kansas’s grew by about 15%, and Kansas’s base still showed up this year.
And it wasn’t simply money. The Republican side spent more overall, but counting every race on the ballot, the Democratic side paid for at least as much door-knocking as the Republican side did.
The voters who didn’t come back
What did change is how Nebraska’s cities treat their newer voters. Since 2016, Omaha’s presidential electorate has grown about 14%, but its midterm electorate has only grown about 8% since 2018. Lincoln looks about the same. In rural Nebraska the two have grown together.
The voter file shows when that started. Of the people in Omaha and Lincoln who first voted in 2016, about 57% came back and voted in the 2018 midterm. In the rest of the state it was 49%. Of the people who first voted in 2020, only about 40% came back for 2022, in the cities and everywhere else alike. The cities used to bring their new voters back for midterms better than the rest of the state did, and in 2022 they stopped.
Where the surge happened
Looking at every state Trump carried, a pattern shows up.
In those states where a Democrat was the main challenger in the U.S. Senate race, the Democratic counties’ gap rose by a median of almost eight points from 2022. That held even where the Democrat had no real chance: Wyoming’s Democratic counties rose ten points while the Democrat lost 65 to 35, Alabama’s thirteen, Kentucky’s six and a half.
In the four Trump states where an independent took the Democrat’s place in the Senate race (Idaho, Montana, Nebraska and South Dakota), the gap barely moved. In the three with a 2022 figure to compare, the median rose less than a point. Idaho’s Democratic counties already had a large gap in 2022, and it didn’t grow.
There’s a second force at work in part of the South. The Brennan Center found that turnout rose as much as ten points over 2022 in majority-minority counties that used to need federal approval to change their voting rules under the Voting Rights Act, and it ties that at least partly to anger over the Supreme Court’s Louisiana v. Callais decision. That likely explains a good share of the biggest jumps on this list: Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana and Georgia were all covered by that law. Nebraska never was, and Omaha’s Black precincts didn’t see a jump like that. But the Senate pattern doesn’t depend on it. Kansas, Iowa, Wyoming, Kentucky and Ohio were never covered either, and their Democratic counties rose anyway, every one of them with a Democrat running for the Senate.
The likely explanation is pretty plain. A Democrat on the Senate ballot tells occasional Democratic voters there’s a race that’s theirs, and it brings the national party’s turnout machinery with it. An independent running for Republican crossover votes has every reason to keep their distance from the Democratic base, and does. In Nebraska there was no Democratic Senate nominee, the Democrat running for governor was outspent about two and a half to one, and the state party had four or five people on payroll. Bringing back the cities’ presidential-year voters wasn’t anyone’s job.
What this does and doesn’t show
This is a pattern across four states, not proof. Florida’s and South Carolina’s Democratic counties did rise with a Democrat in the Senate race, but not far enough to open much of a gap. Alaska has no 2022 figure to compare against, and its gap this year was about zero. County totals describe places, not people. When the state releases the 2026 vote history, it will show voter by voter whether registered Democrats in Omaha and Lincoln stayed home more than their counterparts in Iowa and Kansas.
Some of this was beyond anyone’s control. There was no presidential race to bring the cities’ newer voters out, Omaha started further behind than the winning states’ Democratic counties, and Nebraska didn’t have the Voting Rights Act history that seems to have driven part of the surge in the Deep South. Other parts were choices. Backing an independent for the Senate instead of running a Democrat gave up the kind of turnout boost most Democratic-led states got this year. And nobody built a program to do what a Democratic nominee’s campaign does everywhere else.
That matters for 2030. Without a presidential race on the ballot, someone has to own the job of bringing these voters back, or the same thing will probably happen again.
The Voting Rights Act finding is the Brennan Center’s (”Surprising Turnout Rates in 2026 Midterms”). County totals are each state’s unofficial 2026 results and MIT Election Lab’s county returns for 2016 through 2024. 2018 figures are from MIT Election Lab’s precinct files summed to counties for Iowa, Kansas, Texas and Mississippi, and from the Nebraska Secretary of State. The new-voter figures come from Nebraska’s current voter file, which leaves out people who have since moved away. This will be updated when the 2026 vote history is released.
First published on That's Not How This Works. Subscribe there to get each post by email.